By: Kelly Dietz09/29/2004
On Aug. 13th, a CH-53D helicopter from the U.S. Marine Corps' Futenma Air Station crashed into a residential neighborhood in Ginowan City, Okinawa. It exploded when it slammed into a building just inside the small campus of Okinawa International University, after sending the entire tail assembly, a propeller blade, parts of the fuselage and more than 30 other pieces of debris into the surrounding urban neighborhood. There were no deaths or injuries on the ground, and the crew members walked, assisted, away from the wreckage. But the impact of the crash is still being felt six weeks later.
Ironically, at the time of the crash I was listening to the mayor of Ginowan report on his recent trip to Washington D.C., where he met with U.S. lawmakers about the lack of progress on a 1996 agreement between the U.S. and Japan to close Futenma base. Occupying 1,190 acres in the very center of Ginowan, an average of over 110 flights per day originate from Futenma. Most of these are drills, so helicopters merely circle low over the city before landing. In other words, it was routine policy for the helicopter to fly over a residential neighborhood on Aug. 13. As Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld put it during his visit here last November, "It's a wonder there are not more accidents."
I live about 400 yards from where the helicopter came down. My neighborhood - the whole of Okinawa - is still reeling from the crash. A continuing source of anger, and indeed fear, is the way the U.S. military unilaterally and forcefully took control over the crash site and surrounding neighborhood. Without seeking permission, marines immediately occupied the campus, preventing university authorities and Okinawan police from accessing the site for two full days, and then only allowing observation of the wreckage from a distance.
The military also refused Okinawan authorities' demands to investigate the crash site and wreckage. Footage showing U.S. military personnel in full-body protective gear removing a large covered object, and subsequent footage of the military taking away top soil from the site, fueled concerns about a cover-up by the military. Although the military insisted the aircraft carried no depleted uranium - a radioactive material condemned internationally but still widely used by the U.S. in its weaponry - it later admitted the presence of cancer-causing strontium 90.
Anger turned to rage when the marine base resumed flights just three days after the crash. With the burned-out remains of the helicopter still on the ground and the U.S. military's own investigation into the cause of the crash ongoing, the military justified its resumption of flights by citing "operational necessity" in its war on Iraq.
Images in the news of marines shouting at and using force against residents on the day of the crash, along with accounts of soldiers confiscating film and entering private property without permission, bolster calls for a formal investigation into the military's response.
Not surprisingly, protests occurred almost daily, culminating in a massive rally of 30,000 people at the campus on Sept. 12. But local anger is directed equally at the Japanese government. Prime Minister Koizumi refused to meet with Okinawan officials during his summer holiday. Japan's Foreign Minister suggested the U.S. military did not violate provisions of the agreement spelling out the legal status of U.S. military forces in Japan.
Calls for unconditional closure of Futenma reflect widespread frustration with Japan's dogged support of the U.S. military's desire to relocate the airbase within Okinawa.
What few Americans realize is that 75% percent of all U.S. forces in Japan are located in Okinawa, a mere 0.6 percent of Japan's territory. To put these figures in perspective for Times readers, Okinawa Island, at 476 sq. miles, is just a fraction larger than Tompkins County. In addition to 38 bases, the military also controls 29 sea zones and 20 air spaces here. U.S. forces landed here in early 1945 and never left.
Polls show 80 percent of Okinawans want the U.S. military gone. Eighty four percent want immediate, unconditional closure of Futenma. Ninety four percent oppose the new base. When the Japanese government and US military ignored the results of an official 1997 citizens' referendum, in which a majority of Nago residents voted against the new base, residents began an encampment at the proposed site. Opposition intensified this year, so far successfully preventing the Japanese government's initial drilling of the seabed, scheduled to begin on April 19. The elders leading the Henoko movement, mostly women in their late 70s, vow to give their lives to prevent the construction of yet another US military base on Okinawa.
Kelly Dietz is a visiting researcher at the University of Ryukyus in Okinawa, Japan. She is an Ithaca resident.











