Monday, April 15, 1996

Clinton trip to shift Japan's role in alliance

Barr, Cameron W.,
Christian Science Monitor, 08827729,
4/15/96, Vol. 88, Issue 97

This week's summit between President Clinton and Japanese Prime Minister Ryutaro Hashimoto seems likely to inaugurate a period of expanded and unprecedented military cooperation between their nations.

In a presummit move, the two governments announced on Friday that the US would return a military base that has long rankled residents on the Japanese island of Okinawa. The decision to hand back the Marines' Futenma Air Station in five to seven years is at once an attempt to appease Okinawans and an investment in the future of the US-Japan military alliance.

Ever since the rape of a schoolgirl in Okinawa last September by three US servicemen, Japan and the US have worked to ensure that Okinawan resentment does not turn into a widespread movement to evict the US military from Japan. At the same time, critics of the alliance have been asking what, exactly, are 47,000 US troops doing in Japan?

Answering that question -- in a way that convinces the American and Japanese public -- is the main task that the two leaders face during the April 17-18 summit.

Some Asian observers may see the closure of the Futenma base as a sign of a reduced American commitment in this region, especially in light of the US military's withdrawal from its Philippine outposts in 1992. Although East Asia has witnessed much stability and prosperity in recent years, it is a part of the world where no one takes peace for granted.

The US has fought in three major conflicts in this region in little more than five decades. A partial legacy of those wars is the continued US military presence. Under a defense treaty signed in 1960, Japan is home to an American aircraft carrier and a Marine division -- the only ones of their kind based outside the US -- and a host of other US forces.

Japan's own military is limited by a pacifist Constitution, drafted by US authorities in the wake of World War II, that ensures that Japan maintain only defensive capabilities.

Many leaders and analysts here see the continuance of a US military role in the region as the key to peace. Just last month, US warships were used to warn China not to take its intimidation of Taiwan too far. Likewise, 36,000 US troops help protect South Korea from possible aggression by North Korea.

"The US military's presence," says Seizaburo Sato, a political scientist at Tokyo's Institute for International Policy Studies, "is an absolute prerequisite for the peace and stability of the region." China, with its growing economy and a modernizing military, is the major reason why Asians want the Americans to stay.

In the coming days, US and Japanese officials will take a series of steps regarding their security arrangements. The two sides will announce more efforts to make the US presence in Okinawa prefecture -- where 20 percent of the main island is occupied by US forces -- less burdensome, such as the return of other facilities and plans to curb noise.

The two governments are also expected to sign an agreement that will smooth cooperation between their militaries -- allowing them to provide each other with food, fuel, and spare parts during joint exercises, UN peacekeeping operations, and humanitarian missions.

They will also begin revising guidelines that govern cooperation in more adverse circumstances, such as during a possible crisis in East Asia. Finally, the two leaders will issue a document "reaffirming" their security ties.

Judging from press reports here, this reaffirmation could well be a broadening and deepening of the US-Japanese alliance. As it stands, the treaty signed by the two countries in 1960 is narrow in scope. It obliges the US to defend Japan and Japan to provide the US with facilities to carry out that objective. It also says the US may use these facilities to maintain "international peace and security in the Far East."

There is much speculation in Tokyo that Japan will endorse an expansion of the geographical scope of the US-Japan alliance, offering the US more support in its unofficial role as the policeman of Asia. Such an expansion would also hasten the day when Japanese troops -- most likely in concert with American counterparts -again take part in military activities in other parts of Asia.

A lot will have to happen, however, before that day comes. For one thing, Japan's Constitution forbids the use of force in resolving international disputes. Japanese governments have long interpreted it to mean that Japan may not participate in collective security arrangements, in which several countries come to the aid of another.

THE legacy of World War II has also resulted in a strong pacifist movement in this country that will not easily countenance steps to broaden the activities of Japan's Self-Defense Forces, as the military is known. The Japanese have long been loath to even discuss military and security issues, and even the recent crisis in Taiwan seemed to provoke dread, not debate, from Japanese politicians. But increasingly, those who advocate a more engaged military are raising their voices. "In the case of an emergency, Japanese forces should go with the US," says Professor Sato. "I'm not saying Japan should send combat troops right now, but Japan should not hesitate to help the US."

Even a more dovish thinker, such as Kuniko Inoguchi, a politics professor at Tokyo's Sophia University, advocates "maximum effort" to help the US resolve a crisis in East Asia, even if it involves military action. Should such a crisis crop up, she says, "it has to be quick, and it has to end in victory -- everything must be considered in those terms."

While she rejects the idea of using Japanese troops in combat situations, she does so for practical reasons: "In modern strategic warfare we have a bad record, or no record at all."

It remains to be seen what the Japanese PUblic will make of any effort to have Japan assist the US militarily in Asia. The conventional wisdom says they would bitterly resist such steps. But, insists Hiroyuki Hosoda, a member of parliament from the ruling Liberal Democratic Party, "I think the people would change overnight if they faced an emergency."