
Former Defense Minister Yuriko Koike is watching intently from the sidelines as the scandal over former Vice Defense Minister Takemasa Moriya unfolds. During the summer, Koike and former Chief Cabinet Secretary Yasuhisa Shiozaki were at the center of an intra-government battle to replace Moriya, the top bureaucrat in the ministry. The spat eventually took its toll on Koike, who was replaced after only 55 days in the job, when Prime Minister Shinzo Abe reshuffled his cabinet.
Moriya, who was once dubbed "an emperor" for his extensive influence on defense policy issues, has denied giving any favors to defense equipment traders over procurement of U.S. engines for the next-generation CX aircraft but admitted to having kept "inappropriately" cozy ties for more than a decade with a businessman linked to the firms.
Koike's decision to retire Moriya set off the intra-government battle. Shukan Post asks Koike about her 55 days at the ministry.
The guy whom you fought is now accused of having improper ties with a defense trading company. I think I was right to change the personnel system in the Defence Ministry. Liberal Democratic Party (LDP) and defense officials recently told me that if Moriya were still in power, the Defense Ministry would have even more trouble. They thanked me for kicking him out, but it was not soon enough, I guess.
Did you kick him out because you knew of his scandals?I had heard rumors about Moriya's collusion with corporations before. A Shukan Post article about him published on August reminded me of the Okamitsu case (*). However, I didn't have any evidence to accuse him at that time. Now it's all becoming public. Duringmy tenure, I was mainly concerned with plugging leaks of high-level military information from inside the ministry. I thought th ebest way to do that would be to reform the ministerial structure. That's why I moved Moriya out. I think my decision was right.
Moriya originally welcomed you when you became defense minister.I've heard he called me his "drinking buddy." We did have drinks during briefing sessions several times when I was minister of state for Okinawa and assistant to the prime minister for national security affairs, but not whiel I was defense minister. I nicknamed him "teddy bear" during that time.
However, he lacked manners. He never bowed to me when he left my office, as other defense officials did. He never did so from the beginning. In daily briefings, other officials readily answered m, but not Moriya. He might have thought he could manipulate a new female minister like me.
How did he react when you told him he was out?At first, he gave me a proposal for reshuffling the ministry but it didn't include his retirement. Some people, who didn't know this, criticized me as if I were firing an official who was going to retire. Even after I told him that he would have to move on, I asked him to remain in the ministry as a special adviser because he had passionately worked on the issue of moving U.S. military bases from Okinawa. But he refused my offer, claiming that he couldn't afford to maintain his standard of living in such a position. I felt sad to hear him talk like that.
You felt sad? Why?Well, here was a man who had been in charge of national defense as administrative vice minister. Even if he retires, he would be given a huge amount of retirement benefits. Despite that, he said he wouldn't be able to afford his current lifestyle. I thought to myself that he doesn't have the samurai mentality. Our defense personnel on the front lines, helping to support anti-terrorism operations in the Indian Ocean, Iraq, Golan Heights and other places, would not understand their boss worrying about his life after retirement, esepcially given that it was built on improper ties with corporations.
Shukan Post pointed out in August that Moriya had resisted being retired because he wanted to conclude the CX deal with Nihon Mirise Corp, whose CEO Motonobu Miyazaki has close ties with him.The Defense Ministry seemed to be in a hurry to choose a company to procure General Electric engines for the CX aircraft. When I was the minister, I asked some officials in charge of the contract what the rush was. They said it was just a preliminary decision. Yamada Yoko Corp was originally in line for the contract. Miyazaki had been head of Yamada, but he quit and set up Nihon Mirise in September last year. His cozy ties with Moriya remained but officials said it was no big deal and that it was matter between private corporations. I believe I prevented further troubles by freezing this selection process.”
How did Moriya gain such influential power in the first place?The Defense Ministry had a unique atmosphere within it. Since Moriya's presence is so influential, everybody cares about him. The administrative vice minister usually changes every two years. But he remained in the post for more than four years. In addition, he pays much attention to tiny things and can figure out what people want. In diplomatic and decision-making processes, such an ability is undoubtedly advantageous. He got a lot of supporting comments from LDP politicians when he was retiring.
Do you think former Chief Cabinet Secretary Yasuhisa Shiozaki should have held a meeting to discuss the personnel reshuffle in order to prevent the dispute between yourself and Moriya?The decision to retire Moriya was made through the usual process. However, while Prime Minister Shinzo Abe at the time agreed with the reshuffle, Shiozaki hesitated to call a meeting. I don’t know why he was against it even now.
If you were still defense minister, how would you deal with the present scandal?I already did it. When I was defense minister, the ministry conducted an organizational reform in a large scale. On August 1, the ministry launched the Inspector General’s Office to investigate cartels and information leaks. The head of the office is a former superintendent public prosecutor. This is not a halfway internal inspection process but a serious one. The ministry needs to expose wrongdoings as much as possible in order to restore public trust.
If you were to run into Moriya, what would you say to him?The role of the Defense Ministry is to protect the nation based on public trust. He should have been a role model. I want him to realize that time is being wasted over this scandal when we should be discussing more important issues such as Anti-Terrorism Special Measures Law.
* The Okamitsu case concerned a former administrative vice minister of the Health and Welfare Ministry and his wife who were given an apartment and car worth more than 60 million yen by the owner of a home for the elderly. Okamitsu was arrested in 1996 on bribery charges and sentenced to two years in jail in 2003. (Translated by Taro Fujimoto)October 31, 2007