Friday, August 29, 2008

U.S. sought Japanese defense commitment over Okinawa reversion talks


Date: August 29, 2007

The United States sought an increased defense commitment in the Far East by Japan in exchange for negotiating the reversion of Okinawa Prefecture during a bilateral summit in November 1967 in Washington, according to Japanese diplomatic documents declassified Thursday.

In the talks, Japanese Prime Minister Eisaku Sato urged U.S. President Lyndon Johnson to indicate the timing of Okinawa's reversion, but Johnson instead made a plea for Japan to share the burden of ensuring security in the region as a condition for discussing the matter, the documents show.

Okinawa, which was under U.S. occupation after World War II, was eventually returned to Japan in May 1972 after the two countries agreed in November 1969 on the reversion at a meeting between Sato and then U.S. President Richard Nixon.

The declassified documents do not shed light on confidential negotiations involving Sato's covert emissary and others that are said to have begun prior to the 1967 summit or on a secret pact signed by Sato and Nixon in 1969 allowing the United States to bring nuclear weapons into Okinawa in times of emergency.

References to the confidential negotiations and the secret nuclear agreement have been observed in declassified U.S. documents and remarks by informed individuals.

A full Japanese record of the 1967 summit between Sato and Johnson obtained in 2002 by Kyodo News was 48 pages in all, but the Foreign Ministry declassified only parts of the record this time, amounting to 22 pages.

During the talks, Sato told Johnson that the return of Okinawa to Japan was a ''national wish'' and that mishandling the matter could lead to major problems between their countries, according to the declassified documents.

The Japanese leader said he can understand that the United States cannot say specifically when the territory would be returned, but pressed the U.S. president to eye the reversion ''within two to three years.''

Sato, while mentioning China's nuclear armament, effectively expressed approval for U.S. military bases to remain in Okinawa on a long-term basis, saying it is ''a matter of course that removing the bases in Okinawa is unthinkable.''

He said Japan is considering ''educating its people'' on what can be done concerning the U.S. bases and other issues involving the reversion while making clear that Japan's safety is secured under the U.S. nuclear umbrella.

Johnson refrained from touching on the specific timing of the reversion, and said the United States would welcome an ''offer'' by Japan to increase its defense responsibility ''in that part of the world'' as Washington has exerted itself in fighting in places such as Korea and Vietnam.

The president noted that some Americans were disillusioned that the United States was working for the defense of all other countries and said Washington would be able to ''work on'' the Okinawa reversion issue if Japan were to assume responsibility in economic and other areas.

Akio Takahara, a University of Tokyo professor specializing in East Asian affairs, said Johnson's remarks showed he was so exhausted from dealing with outstanding issues such as the Vietnam War and economic troubles that he thought it inevitable for the United States to make concessions if Japan would take on some extra responsibilities.

Some commentators point out that the situation back then is similar to current times, such as in the cases of Iraq and Afghanistan, when the United States, suffering from deteriorating war situations, is asking for economic or defense-related burden-sharing by Japan, which has bowed to the requests.