
The Yomiuri Shimbun
The following is the first installment of a three-part series on Japan's participation in international antipiracy efforts in the waters off Somalia. Japan's contribution to global security is coming increasingly into the spotlight against the backdrop of efforts to bolster the Japan-U.S. alliance.
"Warning shots by a machine gun should be fired at the surface of the water about 50 meters in front of a pirate vessel."
So reads one restriction on the use of weapons that applies to the two destroyers dispatched by the Maritime Self-Defense Force to waters off Somalia.
If a suspected pirate vessel approaches a Japanese merchant ship, the MSDF destroyers have been told to contact the vessel and advise it to change course immediately or else armed force will be used. However, any warning shots are to be fired within the confines of the above guidelines.
The MSDF recently conducted shooting practice in waters around Japan. During the exercise, a volley was fired from 12.7mm machine guns mounted on a destroyer at a target about 500 meters away. Tracer bullets left red streaks of light that confirmed their trajectory.
But moments later the streaks were seen hitting the crests of waves and ricocheting in every direction.
After watching video footage of the exercise, a senior MSDF officer explained: "Any shots we fire will ricochet dramatically after hitting the water's surface. So we have to be aware of what will happen if we fire any warnings."
Two MSDF destroyers--Samidare and Sazanami--left Kure Port on Sunday for the waters off Somalia. They will conduct warning shot exercises on the high seas almost every day before they arrive in the Gulf of Aden.
About 20,000 vessels travel annually through the Gulf of Aden off Somalia, including about 2,000 ships owned or operated by Japanese shipping companies. Last year, four Japan-connected ships were seized by pirates.
The MSDF mission is to protect Japan-connected ships using the two destroyers and their onboard helicopters.
But the mission is only authorized to engage in maritime policing activities in line with the Self-Defense Forces Law, meaning the destroyers can fire warning shots in the course of their mission, but are not allowed to harm others except in legitimate self-defense, such as when a hostile party opens fire.
The plan to fire a warning shot no closer than 50 meters from suspected pirate vessels was seen as the best way of conforming to these guidelines.
The senior MSDF officer said shooting at such close range likely would be effective in deterring piracy but added, "Given the likelihood that bullets fired as warning shots will ricochet, there's a high possibility that close-range shooting will lead to injury or even death."
Pirates off Somalia are armed with rifles, machine guns and even rocket launchers with a range of more than two kilometers. But unlike other countries' militaries that are dealing with the pirate threat based on the rules of engagement laid out in line with international law, the MSDF has restraints on its use of armed force. This could prove advantageous for pirates.
The government's dispatch of MSDF vessels to join international antipiracy efforts comes five months after it announced it would study such a plan. The government's belated decision likely was prompted by China's launch of its own antipiracy measures.
The seas off Somalia are 12,000 kilometers from Japan, yet the MSDF mission will be expected to apply the same rules to tackling well-armed pirates as it uses when patrolling waters around Japan.
Meanwhile, the ruling coalition has neglected efforts to make the necessary legislative arrangements to promote SDF international peacekeeping activities, even though they were defined two years ago as an essential part of the SDF's work.
As a result, it is the SDF personnel sent overseas to participate in peace missions who are the ultimate victims of inaction.
(Mar. 18, 2009)