Saturday, November 28, 2009

Panel wary over security funding cuts / Screening of 'sympathy budget,' arms issues requires 'political decision' first



    The Yomiuri Shimbun


    The need for a cautious approach and political decisions over sensitive budget requests relating to national security was the order of the day Thursday, judging by comments made by members of a government panel tasked with trimming wasteful government spending.

    The so-called sympathy budget for U.S. military forces in Japan, which includes the wages paid to Japanese staff employed at U.S. military bases, was among the sensitive funding requests examined by the panel.

    Others included budgeting for the Self-Defense Forces to purchase equipment, firearms and ammunition.

    The stance taken by the Government Revitalization Unit in its screening session drew considerable attention among the public and media who were interested to see to what extent the panel's yardstick of cost-effectiveness would be used when it came to looking at sanctuarylike budgets related to national security and the Japan-U.S. alliance.

    Yukio Edano of the Democratic Party of Japan, a former chairman of the party's Policy Research Committee who currently heads the screening panel, acknowledged there were difficulties in assessing the appropriateness of wage levels for people working at U.S. bases in Japan.

    "There is some difficulty in discussing [these issues]," Edano said at the beginning of Thursday's session, referring to the workers' wage levels, which are based on a special agreement between Japan and the United States as well as the employees' union.

    According to the Japan-U.S. Status of Forces Agreement, the United States, which officially employs the workers, is supposed to pay their wages.

    But due to the strength of the yen during the 1980s, the amount the United States had to pay the workers increased substantially, leading Japan and the United States to reach a special, fixed-term agreement over their wages. Based on this agreement, Japan has been paying their wages since fiscal 1987.

    The existing agreement is valid from fiscal 2008 to fiscal 2010 and states that Japan pays the wages of 23,055 of the 25,500 Japanese staff working at the bases. Their wages are calculated in accordance with government employee salary standards and are finalized after the Defense Ministry obtains agreement from the U.S. forces in Japan and the workers' union.

    All 12 members of the screening panel looking into this funding said this particular budget request should be reviewed, but none of them referred to the special Japan-U.S. agreement.

    One panel member said, "In the future, when the special agreement is revised or labor-management negotiations take place, it would be desirable for consideration to be given so that there's a healthy balance between the wages of these workers and those of people engaged in similar work in areas where U.S. military bases are located."

    Akihisa Nagashima, a parliamentary defense secretary who took part in the discussion, was pleased with what he heard.

    "In the past I've questioned whether the sympathy budget was a suitable matter for the screening process, but [during the session] some very useful and convincing suggestions were made," Nagashima said.

    Meanwhile, all manner of opinions were exchanged during discussions over the SDF's purchasing of firearms and ammunition. Some said imported items should be available for use in drills and exercises, while some even said it might be necessary to review or ease the virtual ban on Japanese arms exports to open the door to the exporting of domestic weapons overseas.

    A Defense Ministry official who attended the session objected to the use of imported arms and ammunition.

    "If we rely on imports for our arms and ammunition, concerns will emerge over whether we can secure stable supplies in the event of a state emergency," the official said. "That's the biggest reason for us making a point of sticking to domestically producing supplies."

    However, 11 out of 12 panel members voted for a review of the ministry's arms policy with a view to increasing the possibilities of purchasing imported firearms and ammunition.

    The Defense Ministry also has asked for funding for more Patriot Advanced Capability-3 missiles and other large-scale equipment.

    However, the government has postponed the revision of the National Defense Program Guidelines and the drawing up of the nation's next five-year defense build-up program, and is instead focusing now on the defense budget for fiscal 2010.

    Consequently, seven of the 11 members of the team looking into this issue said a decision on these purchases should not be reached before the National Defense Program Outline is revised and that, as such, a decision could not be made during the session because they should instead wait for a political decision to be made first.

    (Nov. 28, 2009)