Gordon G. Chang, 10.30.09, 12:01 AM EDT
America's dangerously flawed Asia policy.
President Obama starts his November trip to Asia with a visit to Japan. He has four other stops on the itinerary--Singapore, Beijing, Shanghai and Seoul--but none of them will be as interesting as the two days in Tokyo. He arrives in the Japanese capital just weeks after his defense secretary embarrassed the prime minister, insulted Defense Ministry officials and inflamed public opinion.
Once, American presidents took the Japanese for granted. Bill Clinton even failed to touch down in their country as he traveled to and from China in 1998, thereby triggering the "Japan passing" frenzy. It was not so much that Bubba thought the Japanese were has-beens--although there was some of that strain evident in his thinking--it was more that he figured they didn't need attention. Japan, after all, was a reliable friend, the "cornerstone" of America's alliance structure in Asia.
Mr. Obama can go through the motions in the other cities--especially in Beijing where nothing of great importance will occur--but he will have to be alert in Tokyo. There, Japanese diplomacy looks as if it is in the midst of a once-in-a-generation transition, and America's leader will have to be particularly careful.
In September, the Japanese electorate ended the reign of the Liberal Democratic Party, which had governed the country with but one short interruption since 1955. The LDP had built its foreign policy around the military alliance with the U.S., but the party has now lost control of both houses of the Diet, or legislature. Yukio Hatoyama, the new prime minister, says nice things about America--but only when he is prompted to do so. And, significantly, he has signaled he wants to shift Japan's focus to China and the rest of Asia.
As he takes Japan in new directions, Hatoyama is bumping up against Washington. For one thing, he wants to end Japan's eight-year-old refueling site in the Indian Ocean, which supports NATO operations in Afghanistan, as well as investigate secret arrangements reached in the early 1960s regarding the shipment and storage in Japan of American nuclear weapons. Most important, he is now trying to show Japan is an equal partner in the alliance by renegotiating a 2006 agreement to reorganize American forces in his country. A particular sore point is Marine Corps Air Station Futenma, which is located near residential areas on Okinawa. Simply put, the Japanese prime minister wants the base off the island, not merely transferred to another part of it.
The Futenma matter is extremely controversial. An overwhelming majority of Okinawans want the American military to leave, but the Pentagon is adamant about not reopening the deal involving the Air Station's relocation. Defense Secretary Robert Gates, in a visit to Japan last week, publicly shot down the concept of renegotiation in blunt words, embarrassing the Hatoyama government by calling its proposals "immensely complicated and counterproductive" and telling it to "move on." Washington would like to settle the spat before President Obama arrives in Japan on Nov. 12, but Chief Cabinet Secretary Hirofumi Hirano has made it clear there will be no early end to the already nasty disagreement.





