skip to main |
skip to sidebar
Monday, Jan. 25, 2010
Fifty years after the current Japan-U.S. security treaty took effect, 2010 looks to be a watershed year for the bilateral relationship between Japan and the United States.
Prime Minister Yukio Hatoyama's insistence on revisiting a 2006 bilateral agreement calling for the relocation of the U.S. Marine Corps' Air Station Futenma on Okinawa to a less populated site on the island to the north, is straining Japan-U.S. relations. More than 100 days after becoming prime minister, Hatoyama has yet to decide whether to honor the accord.
There are four major problems with the Hatoyama administration's pursuit of its policies toward the U.S.: (1) Hatoyama's lack of understanding of America and Americans, the result of which has led to mismanagement of the alliance relationship and damaged Americans' self-esteem, (2) failure by Hatoyama and his colleagues to build personal ties with the right people in Washington, (3) the Hatoyama administration's inability to draw up long-term strategies for bilateral relations, and (4) Hatoyama's failure to appreciate the cost to Japan if the U.S. withdrew its troops from the country.
Hatoyama does not seem to understand that Americans, who are sometimes criticized for being arrogant, are quite easily hurt. For example, even the administration of President George W. Bush was openly upset when France and Germany did not fully support his war efforts in Iraq. Bush jumped at Japan's decision to support him.
It was against this background that President Barack Obama experienced utter shock when his junior partner in the Pacific appeared to be trying to renege on an earlier promise.
At their meeting in November, Hatoyama told Obama to "trust me" in handling the base relocation issue. Hatoyama is to blame entirely for the discord that ensued. He should have known that Obama would interpret the words from a presumably competent politician as reassurance that the issue would be resolved before yearend, and that Hatoyama would forfeit respect if he intentionally betrayed Obama.
Mutual trust is the prerequisite to any alliance between nations. Should Tokyo lose Washington's trust, Japan would face serious consequences — involving shared military information, commerce, exchange rates and resolution of global issues. Hatoyama has forgotten that his predecessors such as Zenko Suzuki and Morihiro Hosokawa strained relations with the U.S. by hurting Americans' pride.
Before taking over the government, Hatoyama relied on Jitsuro Terashima, chairman of the Japan Research Institute, for advice on diplomatic and security issues. For his part, Terashima had distanced himself from American Japan hands such as former Deputy Secretary of State Richard Armitage; Michael Green, the former senior director for Asian affairs at the National Security Council; and others. In Terashima's view, Japan should work closely with "mainstream" people in Washington.
Hatoyama has kept this posture since becoming prime minister. The trouble is that he has failed to show Washington what global strategies he seeks to pursue other than bilateral ties with the U.S. He has not succeeded in establishing bonds with key figures in Washington as they thought his "diplomacy of fraternity" seemed empty.
Meanwhile, in pursuing his pet theme of reducing reliance on bureaucrats and getting elected politicians to play key roles, Hatoyama has all but put an end to the strategy-building tasks undertaken by the Foreign Policy Bureau of the Foreign Affairs Ministry, created in the early 1990s when the now-opposition Liberal Democratic Party was in power.
Democratic Party of Japan politicians, including Foreign Minister Katsuya Okada, are so inexperienced in diplomacy that they have been busy learning the basics and have had little time to think strategically. Under these circumstances, how does the prime minister expect to translate his oft-repeated slogan of building a "more equal" relationship with the U.S. into action?
Continued indecision on the relocation of the Futenma functions on Okinawa could lead to one of at least two consequences: the base remaining at its present location for as long as no serious military conflict occurs or, in the event of a serious accident involving base aircraft, withdrawal of all U.S. Marines stationed in Okinawa because of local pressure.
Hatoyama is known to have long entertained the idea that, under the Japanese-American security arrangement, U.S. troops should come to the aid of Japan only in times of emergency such as a military conflict with a third nation and that no American forces should be stationed in Japan during peacetime. DPJ secretary general Ichiro Ozawa has echoed this view, adding that Japan needs the presence of the U.S. Seventh Fleet only for protection from outside aggression.
Voices within the U.S. military stress that American troops would be glad to withdraw to Guam or Hawaii, but that there would be no guarantee that the troops would come to defend Japan in case of armed conflicts.
It has been estimated that if Japan, which is flanked on the west by nuclear-armed military powers, were to follow the ideas promulgated by Hatoyama and Ozawa, the nation would have to increase its ¥5 trillion defense budget by 10 percent annually for the next 10 years. Hatoyama's idea that there would be no need for such a military buildup if Japan built a relationship of trust with China is unrealistic.
So, if Japan, while following the fancy of Hatoyama and Ozawa, manages to wreck the relationship of trust built up with the U.S. over decades, the costs could be extremely high.
This is an abridged translation of an article from the January issue of Sentaku, a monthly magazine covering Japanese political, social and economic scenes.
Wednesday, March 11, 2009
Former Prime Minister Yasuhiro Nakasone, who still exerts much influence in Japanese politics at the age of 90, hailed Ichiro Ozawa in an interview toward the end of last year as "having gained dignity, insight and stature during the past year" as the man qualified to lead his Democratic Party of Japan and to replace incumbent Prime Minister Taro Aso of the governing Liberal Democratic Party.
In a more recent television appearance, however, Nakasone said he had some reservations about Ozawa's ability to lead the nation, pointing out that he is lazy, introverted and not in good health.
Of particular concern is Ozawa's health. During the past decade, Japan lost two prime ministers due to health issues: Keizo Obuchi died of a cerebral infraction in 2000 and Shinzo Abe had to resign because of illness in 2007. The respective successors of these leaders, Yoshiro Mori and Yasuo Fukuda, faced many difficulties as a result. This shows that only a physically fit person should take the helm of government.
In a speech delivered shortly after the turn of the year, Nakasone predicted a "major change" in the Japanese political landscape this year, hinting that Aso's LDP will suffer a big setback in the Lower House election, which will be held no later than September, and will hand over the reigns of government to Ozawa's DPJ.
It is important to note, however, that this "change" will not be a result of something drastic coming out of the blue, but rather a culmination of the gradual weakening of the LDP in the past roughly 15 years, as characterized by the advent of coalition politics. The LDP is struggling for survival as its popularity plummets and many of its lawmakers are lamenting that they would be unable to win the next election under Aso's leadership.
Aso was preceded by Fukuda and Abe, each of whom stayed in power only for one year. All three were chosen to head the LDP with an express task of leading the party to victory in the general election. None, however, dared to dissolve the Lower House to call the election. Even though the regime under Aso has lost popularity, the LDP would only be laughed at if it chooses to replace him without going through a general election.
No matter what strategies or tactics the LDP may pursue, it appears all but certain that the next election of the Lower House will mark the end of the rule by the LDP and will usher in a new era in Japanese politics.
Except for a brief period, the LDP has ruled the nation since the party was founded in 1955. This one-party rule has resulted in the loss of its ability to self-reform. The citizens are fed up with a series of gaffes made by the prime minister and the seemingly intoxicated condition of then Finance Minister Shoichi Nakagawa when he met the press in Rome. It would be impossible to reverse the public's ill-feelings toward the LDP even if the party chooses another leader to replace Aso.
The crucial question is who will lead the government after a regime change. If the LDP loses in the next general election, the opposition groups centering around the DPJ are most likely to take over, and Ozawa will become prime minister. There are doubts over his qualifications and ability, however.
Ozawa was criticized for being indecisive when the United States proposed that Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton meet with Ozawa during her visit to Japan last month because the U.S. views him as a leading candidate to be the next prime minister. Ozawa's lieutenants had to persuade their reluctant leader to agree to meet the top diplomat of the new U.S. administration.
At his meeting with Clinton, however, Ozawa was quoted as telling her, "I will never see you again if I fail to take over the reigns of government in the coming general election." This has led some to wonder if he has sufficient diplomatic common sense. (Newspaper polls taken after the arrest of Ozawa's chief secretary over political donation irregularities show that a majority think that Ozawa should resign as DPJ chief. However, more people continue to think that Ozawa is better qualified than Aso to serve as prime minister than people who think the opposite, and the number of people who want a DPJ-led government outnumber those who want the LDP to continue to lead.)
A Lower House election is imminent because even if Aso continues to avoid dissolving the Lower House, the tenure of its members will expire in September. But everything seems to be working against the LDP, which today commands 296 of the 480 seats in the Lower House. Party officials are desperate to win at least 200 seats in the next election. If that materializes, the likely scenario would be for the DPJ to win about 230 seats. That would give today's No. 1 opposition party a plurality in the House, but not a majority. If the DPJ were to win a majority of 241 seats on its own, it would mean more than doubling the 113 seats it now holds. This will not be an easy task.
Should the DPJ win more than 241 seats, Ozawa, as party leader, would become prime minister and probably form a coalition with other groups that are currently in the opposition camp. But an important question is what Ozawa would do if his party becomes the largest group in the House but fails to win a majority.
A number of observers have predicted that in such an event, Ozawa would pick one of his confidants to head the government and he himself would assume the post of deputy prime minister with the power of a kingmaker. By so doing, the observers say, Ozawa will aim to cause a split among the LDP members of the Diet.
They point out in this connection that Ozawa, while bitterly reproaching Aso, speaks very highly of Kaoru Yosano, finance minister and reputedly the prime minister's right-hand man, presumably with a view to driving a wedge between them.
It is incumbent upon Ozawa to maximize the transparency of what he says and what he intends to do. Absent such transparency, Japanese politics could be headed for a new round of chaos.
This is an abridged translation of an article from the March issue of Sentaku, a monthly magazine covering Japanese political, social and economic scenes.
SENTAKU MAGAZINE
Tuesday, Dec. 23, 2008
As the odds grow that the No. 1 opposition Democratic Party of Japan will take the reigns of government after the next general elections, the focus in the Japanese political arena is shifting to the lineup of a Cabinet headed by DPJ leader Ichiro Ozawa, and to who would succeed him if he retired early for health reasons.
Although Prime Minister Taro Aso has apparently decided not to dissolve the Lower House anytime soon, many insiders believe that his repeated verbal lapses and the discord within his Liberal Democratic Party make it extremely difficult for the LDP to maintain a parliamentary majority even if Aso keeps putting off general elections until the current tenure of lawmakers expires next September.
LDP legislators are split over how to review the privatization of the postal services and other issues. Moreover, Komeito, the junior partner in the ruling coalition, is disgusted because Aso has turned down its request for early general elections. These and other factors have led one senior LDP leader to lament there is a 99 percent chance of the birth of a DPJ-led government sometime in 2009.
If the DPJ wins a majority in the Lower House election, Ozawa as its leader would be the natural choice to be named prime minister. The question, though, is whether his health would hold. He has a chronic heart disease and is under strict orders from his physicians to rest after lunch. This would make it strenuous for him to attend deliberations of the all-important Budget Committee in both chambers of the Diet, which normally meets from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m.
Even one of his supporters has confided that Ozawa would probably would not be able to remain in his post for more than three to six months.
After winning in the Upper House election in the summer of last year, the DPJ formed a "shadow Cabinet." There is no guarantee, however, that the current lineup will be maintained after the next election. Indeed, Ozawa is said to be aiming for a big surprise by announcing new members of the shadow Cabinet right after the Lower House is dissolved.
Three people from outside of the political world are regarded as likely to be given Cabinet posts under Ozawa: • Jituro Terashima, chairman of the Mitsui Global Strategic Studies Institute. • Kiyoshi Sasamori, former chairman of the Japan Trade Union Confederation. • Eisuke Sakakibara, a former Finance Ministry official who has played an important role in drafting the DPJ's election campaign manifesto.
The main issue is how Ozawa will treat his three top lieutenants: Naoto Kan, Yukio Hatoyama and Katsuya Okada. And will any one of them be picked as deputy prime minister and thus regarded as the "heir apparent"? A group of DPJ lawmakers have long hoped that Okada would succeed Ozawa, but that appears to be a long shot because the two do not share the same political ideologies.
In a recent magazine article titled "I Am Different From Mr. Ozawa," Okada distanced himself from Ozawa concerning revenue sources for policy measures and other matters. A ranking party official said Ozawa is suspicious that the political agenda he has built up so far might be destroyed by Okada.
Another veteran lawmaker has described Okada as so loyal to his boss that there is little or no possibility of his turning against Ozawa. The likely post that Okada would be given in an Ozawa administration is probably that of chief Cabinet secretary, the prime minister's right-hand man and government spokesman.
As for Kan, who lost to Ozawa in the 2006 party leadership contest, he has refrained from joining intraparty groups critical of Ozawa and has remained quiet in the apparent hope that Ozawa will "peacefully abdicate" his post to him. But a well-informed source counters that Ozawa does not fully trust Kan, whose political career is traced to the more leftist-leaning and now-defunct Social Democratic Federation.
As if to prove the point, Ozawa chose party secretary general Hatoyama, rather than shadow Cabinet deputy premier Kan, to represent him at a meeting with Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh on Oct. 23, when ill health prevented Ozawa from greeting the visitor in person.
Nevertheless, Ozawa's close aides seem to rule out the possibility of Hatoyama assuming the No. 2 position in an Ozawa administration. The reason is that once Hatoyama is given the position of deputy prime minister, they say, supporters of Kan and Okada will start maneuvering against him, and Ozawa doesn't want a power struggle within the party. The probable scenario, according to these aides, is that Ozawa will keep Hatoyama as party secretary general and have him compete against Kan in the race for the party's leadership.
If the DPJ wins in the next general elections, Ozawa is expected to strengthen his political foundation not only by forming an alliance with the Social Democratic Party and the People's New Party but also by inviting in LDP heavyweights unhappy with Prime Minister Aso, such as former LDP secretary general Koichi Kato and former trade minister Takeo Hiranuma, who was thrown out of the LDP for opposing the postal privatization.
Aso and his supporters fear that Ozawa will do everything possible to weaken or destroy the LDP so as not to repeat the failures of 15 years ago when Morihiro Hosokawa was made prime minister.
Since DPJ leaders admit that Ozawa does not generally consult close associates when making important appointments, it is impossible to know what surprise card he has up his sleeve.
Here is the likely makeup of an Ozawa Cabinet: Prime Minister Ichiro Ozawa; Chief Cabinet Secretary Katsuya Okada; Minister Without Portfolio Yukio Hatoyama; Internal Affairs Minister Hirotaka Akamatsu; Justice Minister Tatsuo Kawabata; Foreign Minister Koichi Kato, who will probably have left the LDP by then; Finance Minister Eisuke Sakakibara, a nonpolitician; Education and Science Minister Takeo Hiranuma, an independent; Welfare-Labor Minister Akira Nagatsuma; Trade and Industry Minister Shizuka Kamei of the People's New Party; Land-Transport Minister Kiyoshi Sasamori, a nonpolitician; Environment Minister Mizuho Fukushima, head of the Social Democratic Party; Defense Minister Yoshihiko Noda; Public Safety Commission Chairman Masayuki Naoshima; Minister in Charge of Administrative Reform Naoto Kan; Minister in Charge of Economic and Fiscal Affairs Jituro Terashima, a nonpolitician; and Minister in Charge of Local Autonomy Yasuo Tanaka of the New Party Nippon.
This is an abridged translation of an article from the December issue of Sentaku, a monthly magazine covering Japanese political, social and economic scenes.
Monday, Oct. 29, 2007
SENTAKU MAGAZINE
UPHILL FIGHT FOR DPJ
Ichiro Ozawa's leadership within the Democratic Party of Japan has become stronger than ever following the party's resounding victory in the July 29 Upper House election.
Even those who had thought his leadership would come to an end with that election are now increasingly relying on him to lead the party to another victory in the general election of the Lower House expected in the not-too-distant future.
When former Prime Minister Shinzo Abe abruptly announced his resignation, Ozawa was all smiles, showing every confidence to reporters that it was his party's Upper House election victory that forced Abe to step down.
His confidence did not last for long, however, as a number of DPJ lower house members paradoxically felt that Abe's resignation came too soon and would work against them in the next election. Indeed, Koze Watanabe and other senior party leaders admitted that the Liberal Democratic Party under Abe would have been easier to beat, and said things have changed with Yasuo Fukuda at the helm of the LDP.
Ozawa's basic strategy has been to force the government to dissolve the Lower House and call an early general election while his leadership remains intact on the strength of the DPJ's Upper House election victory. But things aren't all that simple for the DPJ, which is regarded by many as "congeries" of groups with different political backgrounds — one led by former party president Seiji Maehara, another by secretary general Yukio Hatoyama, a group of lawmakers who had belonged to the former Democratic Socialist Party and the Social Democratic Party, and those who defected from the LDP with Ozawa.
In addition to these political backgrounds, there are policy differences among DPJ members of the legislature, ranging from rightwingers led by Maehara to ex-Socialists who are staunchly opposed to amending the war-renouncing Article 9 of the Constitution.
Despite the Upper House election victory, the DPJ, due to this lack of party cohesion, has failed to gain full-fledged recognition from the general public as an equal rival in a new two-party system.
Nevertheless, one cannot underestimate the significance of the DPJ's depriving the LDP of a majority in the Upper House. The effect will last for at least three years and possibly another six years. Even if the LDP wins in the Lower House election, it will remain a minority party in the upper chamber, leaving the nation's political landscape in a state of instability.
Moreover, the LDP could lose the all-important two-thirds majority in the Lower House or even fall into a minority status, which would mean transferring control of the government to the DPJ.
Even though DPJ secretary general Hatoyama has repeatedly called for an early dissolution of the Lower House, his party has a lot of homework to do. In fact, the DPJ has yet to select candidates for about 100 of 300 constituencies. Its attempts to form political alliances with the People's New Party and the Social Democratic Party have not made much headway.
One factor favoring the DPJ in the next general election is that the Japan Communist Party has changed its long-standing policy of fielding one candidate for each of 300 constituencies regardless of its chances of winning. It now appears that the Communists will be contesting races in only about 130 districts. Although it is preposterous to expect the DPJ to garner all would-be Communist votes, this change seems certain to help DPJ candidates nonetheless.
The focus of Ozawa's strategy of trying to force the government to call an early general election is his opposition to having the Maritime Self-Defense Force continue its mission of supplying fuel to U.S. naval and allied vessels in the Indian Ocean as part of the international fight against terrorism. With the fuel-supply law due to expire Nov. 1, the government and the LDP ruling coalition and New Komeito are trying to pass legislation to extend the mission.
As the basis for opposing the MSDF operations, Ozawa points out that such action is not justified by any resolution adopted by the United Nations. At his meeting with U.S. Ambassador to Japan J. Thomas Schieffer, he unequivocally expressed his opposition.
Within the DPJ ranks, however, voices have opined that the fuel-supply operations are a good way in which Japan can cooperate with other countries in fighting terrorism. What bothers the DPJ of late is that, according to various opinion polls, opposition to the Indian Ocean mission is losing steam.
The government, meanwhile, has succeeded in persuading the U.N. Security Council to adopt a resolution expressing appreciation to Japan for cooperating in the antiterrorist campaign by means of the fuel-supply operations.
All of this has created uneasiness among some Democrats, who wonder whether continued opposition to the MSDF operations will work to their advantage in the election campaign.
Ozawa, meanwhile, is bent on building a good track record for his party's policies by presenting a series of legislative bills to the Upper House, where the DPJ holds a majority. Bills related to the national pension system and farm subsidies — both pledged by the party during the Upper House election campaign — have already been submitted.
These DPJ-sponsored bills are certain to pass the Upper House, but there is little chance of their making it through the Lower House, where the ruling coalition still holds sway.
If the dissolution of the Lower House and the subsequent general election are delayed for too long, there is the danger that the general public will become fed up with the DPJ for failing to translate their pledges into action. It is for this reason that the new Fukuda regime will do everything in its power to put off the general election as it recovers from the shock of Abe's sudden resignation.
Ex-DPJ president Katsuya Okada appears concerned that many lawmakers are keeping themselves busy studying policy matters to prepare for the imminent Lower House election. He is urging them to return to their constituencies and make contact with voters.
Ozawa seems to feel the same way, and will launch a nationwide tour in a determined bid to win votes in single-member constituencies.
This is an abridged translation of an article that appeared in the October issue of Sentaku, a monthly magazine of in-depth analysis of Japan's political, social and economic landscape.