By David PillingPublished: September 23 2009 20:46 | Last updated: September 23 2009 20:46
To hear some people in Washington tell it, you would think the Japanese had just made Hugo Chávez their paramount leader. The pledge by Yukio Hatoyama’s victorious Democratic Party of Japan to carve out a foreign policy “less dependent” on the US, plus the newly anointed prime minister’s doubts about what he called “US-led market fundamentalism” have been received with all the equanimity that might have greeted a decision to sequester American oil assets.
The conservative Heritage Foundation was one of many to hit the panic button. On the day the DPJ broke the Liberal Democratic party’s half-century grip on power, it detected a “rumbling across the Pacific Ocean” and the ascent of a “left-of-centre party that has long spouted anti-capitalist and anti-US rhetoric”. Even officials inside Mr Obama’s administration have been privately nervous about the implications for the US-Japan alliance, which has for 60 years helped keep peace in a region still bristling with wartime rancour.
They should not be. Mr Hatoyama is right. US-Japan relations need retuning. The image most often trotted out is of master and poodle. The US defends a nominally demilitarised Japan with nuclear weapons and 50,000 troops stationed on Japanese soil, for which it receives cash and slavish loyalty. But that characterisation does not fit the facts. If Japan is a US pet, it is more strong-willed cat than poodle, wont to wander off whenever it pleases.
Far from showing slavish obedience, Japan has repeatedly defied the US while maintaining the fiction that the two are indivisible. Ever since the Korean war, for example, Washington has sought to persuade Tokyo to jettison pacifist clauses in its constitution, a document the Americans regretted writing almost as soon as the ink was dry. But Japan has refused. Early LDP leaders judged it far better to shelter under America’s subsidised defence umbrella while Japan concentrated on the business of getting rich. Japan spends less than 1 per cent of national output on defence, a quarter of the US relative outlay. True, some LDP nationalists, most recently Shinzo Abe, prime minister in 2006-07, have sought to release Japan from its pacifist shackles. But they failed to overcome domestic opposition.
The relationship, though vital to both sides, has become a tug of war. Japan’s strongest supporters in Washington, prone to see the alliance through khaki-coloured spectacles, are forever convinced that Japan is on the verge of pulling its weight. They point to efforts by former prime minister Junichiro Koizumi, so pro-American he cut a record of Elvis Presley songs, to dispatch ground forces to Iraq and to refuel allied ships in the Indian Ocean. But both those contributions were heavier on symbolism than utility and cost far less than the billions of dollars Japan sent for the first Gulf war.
Nor has Japan been exactly malleable when it comes to US-base deployment. A longstanding deal to move a helicopter base on Okinawa has never been implemented. (That makes the DPJ’s determination to re-examine the agreement less than dramatic). Officials in Washington, while publicly full of praise for Japan’s loyalty, have privately fumed at its stubbornness. Meanwhile, in Tokyo, officials have gnashed their teeth at US policy, most recently when, over Japan’s strong objections, Washington took North Korea off a list of state sponsors of terrorism.
Given such unspoken tensions, Washington should be giddy at the DPJ’s promise to build a more equal, open alliance. It needs a partner that can confidently make agreements and stick to them, not one that is constantly brooding about being pushed around. Mr Obama, who met Mr Hatoyama for the first time yesterday, should also welcome the DPJ’s aim of building closer ties with Asian neighbours, a stark contrast with Mr Koizumi’s terrible relationship with China.
The DPJ also holds the prospect of taking US ties beyond trade and bases. One of Mr Hatoyama’s first acts was to make a bold (some might say reckless) pledge to cut carbon emissions 25 per cent from 1990 levels by 2020 and to help developing countries, including China, to improve their energy efficiency. His government is also seeking to break with decades of economic policy built on exports by stimulating consumer demand, a policy in line with US thinking on global rebalancing.
To be fair, Mr Obama’s administration has taken a sensibly pragmatic stance. It has given Mr Hatoyama breathing room over Okinawa. Kurt Campbell, US assistant secretary of state for east Asian affairs and a man with a wealth of Japanese experience, has responded warmly to the new government’s tone, saying: “It’s important that Japan feels confident and independent.”
That is the right approach. Certainly, it would be easy to scoff at Mr Hatoyama’s flaky rhetoric about “fraternity” and east Asian integration. His wife’s revelation that she travelled by UFO to Venus – she is a star of Japan’s notoriously silly daytime television – is a gift for anyone wanting to mock Tokyo’s new government. As for Mr Hatoyama’s supposedly anti-capitalist rhetoric: just imagine he had said his government stood poised to embrace US-led market fundamentalism. That really would have been scary.
david.pilling@ft.com