Sunday, September 27, 2009

Perspectives :: Birth of Hatoyama's 'science' administration a step away from previous conceptions


September 27, 2009

Having studied applied mathematics at the University of Tokyo's Faculty of Engineering, and holding a doctorate, newly elected premier Yukio Hatoyama is the first "science" prime minister.

Central figures in the Hatoyama administration are also occupied by those with a science background. Those in the field of science who have obscurely supported Japan since the Meiji Period have now set their foot onstage. The capabilities of the Hatoyama administration remain to be tested but I am focused on the administration's potential to change a society that has been led by the humanities.

When the Mainichi's column "Rikei Hakusho" (Science White Paper), which started in January 2002, was compiled into a book in June 2003, the subheading attached by the editor was "The people who silently support our country." People with science backgrounds who had studied science, engineering, agriculture and other subjects at universities and graduate schools had contributed to society, but they were far separated from the upper echelons of organizations in society.

Japan's bureaucracy typifies this structure. When devoted bureaucrats are first taken on, the percentage of administrative officials (from the humanities) and technical officials (from the sciences) is about half and half. But over 90 percent of the top administrative vice ministers are officials who have graduated from the University of Tokyo's Faculty of Law.

A report on the history of the Ministry of Industry in 1871 proclaims, "Technical bureaucrats should be positioned lower than administrative bureaucrats." The tradition of the humanities taking priority over the sciences, with the humanities making the decisions and the sciences following suit, continues today.

In the political world it remains an absolute fact that there are far fewer people from science backgrounds. It is said that about 10 percent of Diet members have backgrounds in science. That's exactly what makes the new administration stand out. Deputy Prime Minister Naoto Kan studied applied physics at the Tokyo Institute of Technology. Chief Cabinet Secretary Hirofumi Hirano worked for Matsushita Electrical Industrial Co. (now Panasonic), after graduating from Chuo University's Faculty of Science and Engineering. Minister of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology Tatsuo Kawabata has a background working in Toray Industries' Research and Development field. Of the 18 Cabinet members, four, including the prime minister, are from science backgrounds.

The main personnel supply source of the Liberal Democratic Party (LDP), which dominated Japanese politics during the postwar period, was formed by bureaucrats and the children of Diet members, and there was no room to admit politicians from science backgrounds. The Democratic Party of Japan (DPJ), on the other hand, has many self-reliant members, such as those from labor unions, and people who cannot rely on territorial bonds, family ties or block votes. Among these, many have come from science backgrounds. This prevalence of people who studied the sciences can probably be viewed as one of the accomplishments of the change in administration.

It was in postwar Japan that the humanities group comprised of the political world, the financial sector and bureaucrats decided on the course for the future. In actual fact, the process lying behind Japan's period of high economic growth involved the humanities making the decision, the sciences producing a product, and the humanities selling it. But that process is now outdated. Japan cannot focus solely on its own happiness; it is expected to tune in to the various difficult problems that the world faces.

Hatoyama has declared that Japan aims to make a 25 percent cut in greenhouse gas emissions from 1990 levels by 2020, and has received a positive evaluation from international society. One of the reasons that the LDP could not lay down active global warming countermeasures was probably that it was making considerations for the business world. It is an interesting fact that when the government administration changed hands, the Japan Business Federation, which had been hesitant about adopting global warming countermeasures, distanced itself from the DPJ, and the presence of the Japan Association of Corporate Executives, whose membership comprises individual corporate managers, grew stronger. The chairman of that association, Masamitsu Sakurai, graduated from Waseda University's Faculty of Science and Engineering, and his cherished opinion is that companies should also bear an appropriate amount of responsibility. Judging the situation through the analysis of data without feeling constrained by bonds can be described as a specialty of the sciences.

Atsushi Sunami, an associate professor at the National Graduate Institute for Policy Studies who is familiar with the relationship between politics and science, sees hope for leaders versed in science and technology.

"In international society, leaders with an understanding of science and technology will be at an advantage in the future," Sunami says. It has become increasingly common for science and technology to show its face in diplomacy through such issues as global warming countermeasures and the development of developing countries. But Sunami adds that cooperation with the humanities is still needed.

"Those from the sciences tend to downplay communication or fail to provide sufficient explanations. They need to make an effort to cooperate with the brains of the humanities and make up for their deficiencies," he says.

The birth of Hatoyama's "science" administration can be seen as the first step for Japan in transforming itself into a society that does not divide up the sciences and humanities. In addition to revisions to the education system that divides students into humanities and science courses while they are studying at high school, society needs to change its way of thinking. I want to keep watch with expectations over the quiet revolution that the change in administration has brought about. ("As I see it" by Yukiko Motomura, Science and Environment News Department)

(Mainichi Japan) September 27, 2009