
Kohei Kobayashi and Kazuki Nishihara / Yomiuri Shimbun Staff Writers
Prime Minister Yasuo Fukuda's strong determination to move forward on civil service reform turned the tide to help make a bill to reform the nation's civil service system likely pass the Diet.
Along with Fukuda's push, the measure benefited from the ruling and opposition parties reaching the political judgement that it would be better to reach an agreement and avoid being blamed for the failure of the reform.
The bill to reform the public service personnel system passed the House of Representatives Committee with support from both the Liberal Democratic Party-New Komeito ruling bloc and the opposition Democratic Party of Japan as all agreed on amendments to the initial bill proposed by the government.
It was initially thought the legislation would not progress during the current Diet session due to strong conflict over the issue between the ruling parties and the DPJ.
Chief Cabinet Secretary Nobutaka Machimura stressed at a press conference Tuesday evening that the ruling bloc agreed on the amendments earlier in the day to the bill at Fukuda's initiative.
"Fukuda has expressed his strong determination to pass the bill and exercised strong leadership within the party for that purpose," Machimura said. "I welcome [the agreement] because it helped realize the prime minister's hope."
Indeed, it was the prime minister's strong wishes pushed the ruling parties, which initially were reluctant to craft a compromise on the issue with the DPJ, to reach an agreement.
On the afternoon of May 15, Fukuda met LDP Diet Affairs Committee Chairman Tadamori Oshima and New Komeito counterpart Yoshio Urushibara, asking for their help to pass the bill during the current Diet session.
The meeting prompted the ruling bloc to accelerate working-level talks.
In addition, Hidenao Nakagawa, former LDP secretary general, said that without compromise with the DPJ, the ruling parties would unavoidably face criticism that they bungled the bill.
Since early this month, Fukuda also has indicated the importance of taking the first step forward in civil service reform even if the bill needed to be amended, according to sources close to the prime minister.
Fukuda is believed to have wanted to make a good impression amid the unusual political situation in which the lower house is dominated by the ruling bloc while the House of Councillors is controlled by the opposition parties.
According to the sources, he even requested a senior member of the Japanese Trade Union Confederation, one of the DPJ's supporters, to exercise his influence over the DPJ.
The bill, amended in response to Fukuda's lobbying efforts, reflects nearly all of what the DPJ has suggested, except for prohibiting amakudari--the appointing of senior bureaucrats to postretirement jobs related to the sectors they formerly oversaw.
Because the revised bill had no clause regulating lawmakers contact with bureaucrats, which was strongly opposed by members of the ruling parties, the ruling bloc found it easier to accept the bill.
However, despite the ruling and opposition parties' agreement, the bill only formulates basic outlines of the reform for the next five years, without addressing the necessity to revise related laws, including the National Civil Service Law and the Cabinet Law, to fully achieve the legislation's goals.
Therefore, further confrontation between the ruling bloc and DPJ remains likely over the revision of the laws in the future.
===
Ruling bloc 'swallows' DPJ ideas
The DPJ reversed its initial stance against the reform bill because it also "wanted to avoid being blamed by the government and ruling bloc for the failure of the reform," a senior DPJ member said.
DPJ Secretary General Yukio Hatoyama initially criticized the bill drawn up by the government, saying: "It contains no regulation to address amakudari. So it merely results in the continuation of the practice."
However, other DPJ members involved in policymaking had different thoughts on the reform. "We have to draw up a better reform bill because only central government bureaucrats will be pleased with its failure," said Jun Azumi, deputy chairman of the DPJ Diet Affairs Committee.
As the next general election appears increasingly unlikely to be held in the near future, DPJ members apparently judged that it would be better to raise the issue of amakudari again immediately before the election, instead of just opposing the government-initiated bill by sticking to standard party policy positions.
DPJ members also believed that they would be able to provoke the LDP by voicing approval for the government's bill because there were likely a considerable number of LDP members who were reluctant to support the bill.
DPJ leader Ichiro Ozawa said: "The government bill is merely makeshift and low level. We have to overhaul the country's entire structure of government."
However, he allowed a DPJ party member handling the issue to decide whether to enter talks on amending the bill.
On Monday evening, senior DPJ members, including Ozawa, met and decided that the party would support the bill if they could amend it in a way they favored.
DPJ Diet Affairs Committee Chairman Kenji Yamaoka said, "Senior LDP officials in favor of representing [the interests of] bureaucrats and those close to the government attempted to water down the bill" between Monday night and Tuesday morning.
However, at working-level talks, the ruling bloc went along with almost everything the DPJ proposed, he said. As a result, agreement was reached.
On Tuesday evening, Yamaoka said at the DPJ headquarters building, "The ban on amakudari is what the DPJ must do after taking office. Except for that, I believe the party scored more than 90 out of 100 points [in terms of what it set out to accomplish with this bill]."
(May. 29, 2008)