Thursday, May 22, 2008By KAKUMI KOBAYASHI
Kyodo News
Shift away from nonmilitary uses prompted by China's military buildup, ballistic missile threat posed by North Korea
In a significant departure from Japan's decades-old adherence to the nonmilitary use of space, the Diet passed a new law Wednesday allowing use of space for national security purposes, avoiding discussion on whether the law is valid under the war-renouncing Constitution.
While many lawmakers say Japan still holds to a "nonaggression" principle in space projects, pundits warn that in the face of China's growing military presence in space and North Korea's ballistic missile development, the law could inevitably take Japan's defense capabilities beyond constitutional restrictions.
The law permits Japan to use and develop space in ways that contribute to its national security, a sharp contrast with the past position that the use of space should be limited to peaceful purposes only.
Although Japan has no immediate plans for a new defense project in space, there is speculation that the law will help boost the space industry and lead to the development of an early warning satellite to detect signs of a ballistic missile launch and to the development of a full-scale spy satellite capable of identifying objects as small as 15 cm in diameter.
Japan already has intelligence-gathering satellites but these are thought to fall short of military-level performance.
"The new space law is a preparatory step for Japan to have its own early warning satellite," a veteran lawmaker who formerly headed the Defense Agency, the predecessor of the Defense Ministry, said.
Setsuko Aoki, an expert on space law, indicated Japan should join in the military use of space with other countries.
"If so, Japan would have a greater say in international efforts to create peace and raise transparency in satellite operations" through future space projects such as the joint management of satellites with other parts of Asia, said the professor at Keio University's Policy Management Department.
It appeared unrealistic for Japan to maintain its "peaceful use only" position when space technologies have developed to the point where it is difficult to draw the line between military and civilian use, Aoki said.
"Production of higher-resolution spy satellites or early warning satellites would benefit Japan's space industry for the time being. That is a hidden purpose of the law," she added.
Despite Japan's global reputation as a high-tech nation, the country's space industry lags "more than 10 years" behind other countries, including China, India and the United States, she said.
The law was sponsored by a bipartisan group of lawmakers from Prime Minister Yasuo Fukuda's Liberal Democratic Party-New Komeito ruling coalition, as well as the Democratic Party of Japan, the main opposition presence in the Diet.
The lawmakers presented a bill for the space law to a House of Representatives panel on May 9 and pushed it through the Lower House and the House of Councilors in less than two weeks.
Atsushi Fujioka, an expert on the U.S. economy at Ritsumeikan University, said the lawmakers apparently wanted to pass the bill before U.S. President George W. Bush leaves office.
"If the Democrats take power in the United States, a new president could be less interested in space projects, including a missile shield," and the Japanese lawmakers thought it would be more difficult to enact this kind of space law under such conditions, said Fujioka, a professor of the university's College of Economics.
The Japanese Communist Party and Social Democratic Party opposed the law.
SDP Secretary General Yasumasa Shigeno warned there is something dangerous behind the law.
The party is known for its peace-oriented policy and fully backs Article 9 of the Constitution, which "forever" renounces war.
Fujioka, another opponent of the law, warns Japan could face difficulties if it tries to involve itself deeply in defense programs in space with the U.S.
"Now is the time when the main theater of war is space. . . . I believe the United States has about 300 satellites and one-third of the total are for military use," Fujioka said.
"In the U.S. attack on Iraq, for example, roughly 70 percent of missiles were precision-guided by satellites," Fujioka said.
China shocked Japan and other countries in January 2007 when it destroyed an aging weather satellite some 850 km above Sichuan Province with a ballistic missile, showing it was capable of wiping out satellites in orbit.
"Space projects are expensive, and it is hard to predict how much they will cost before they begin," Fujioka said, urging Japan to invest more money and energy in bread-and-butter issues such as addressing the widening gap between rich and poor and the collapsing pension system.
Whether to use space for defense purposes has been a politically sensitive topic for decades.
After ratifying the U.N. Outer Space Treaty in 1967, the Diet adopted its own resolution in 1969, which stated that the development of objects for use in space, and of the rockets to put them there, should be limited to peaceful uses only.
The resolution strongly affected space policy, and successive governments stopped short of expanding it to include defense capabilities.
But in 1998, North Korea test-launched a Taepodong-1 ballistic missile, part of which flew over Japanese territory. The incident shocked the government, prompting it to beef up its missile shield.
Japan has launched four satellites since 2003 to gather intelligence, including information on North Korea's missile-related facilities.
But the satellites have a resolution no higher than 1 meter, a commercial-use level, for fear that a better-performing satellite could draw criticism that Japan was trying to expand its defense capability into space.