Sunday, July 25, 2010

Perspectives :: Diet members' move into bigger offices no occasion for celebration

    July 25, 2010

    Amid soaring summer temperatures, lawmakers are continuing to filter into newly constructed offices in the capital's political district, gearing up for an extraordinary session of the Diet starting on July 30.

    As of the end of last week, all House of Representatives members and all House of Councillors members whose seats were not contested in this month's election had moved into the new offices. Upper house members who won seats in the election are expected to finish moving soon.

    The new Diet members' offices are located on the west side of the Diet building in Tokyo's Nagatacho district. The grandly designed buildings offer more than double the space of the previous offices, but sadly, they inspire no hope in a politician-led government; rather they serve as an obstacle to such an ideal.

    Despite Japan facing an age of economizing and tax hikes, construction of the lawmakers' new offices surged ahead. Something seems amiss with a reform-minded administration failing to take issue with this unbalanced situation, and the attitude of the ruling parties -- that nothing can be done about something that is already completed -- is concerning.

    Lawmakers from the lower house occupy two of the new office buildings, while upper house Diet members fill the remaining one. The new buildings were constructed following the demolition of facilities including a parking lot next to the old offices. In the future the old offices will also be demolished and a new parking area created.

    In the new facilities, the average size of each office has been expanded to 100 square meters, much larger than the 40 square meters of the old building. Furthermore, the new office buildings are 12 stories high, compared to seven stories before, and the total floor space is three times that of the old facilities.

    Having stood for half a century, the old Diet members' offices were dilapidated, and there is nothing wrong with rebuilding them. Completion of the new offices offers more convenience for our elected representatives. But at the same time something has been lost -- namely sympathy from the general public. While facing an unprecedented economic crisis, the executives who have been telling company employees to grin and bear it have gone ahead and opened up a new executive office.

    Furthermore, the buildings that form this new executive office are furnished with brand-name fittings including Italian brand Cassina and the U.S. brand Herman Miller. How can this possibly win understanding from the public? And just how does the government plan to succeed in financial reconstruction? It is fitting to say that this type of confused situation is rare in the history of government administration.

    Thinking about modest dwellings of Japan's top elite, we recall those of Toshio Doko, the late fourth-generation chairman of the Japan Federation of Economic Organizations (Keidanren). He served as president of Ishikawajima-Harima Heavy Industries and Toshiba Corp., and was a major business figure, but throughout his life he continued to live in an old home that his aged mother had left behind for him in Yokohama's Tsurumi Ward.

    In 1982, the 85-year-old Doko, then chairman of Ad Hoc Commission on Administrative Reform in the Cabinet of former Prime Minister Zenko Suzuki, was shown on television eating a meal modestly complemented by dried sardines at this dwelling with his elderly wife -- earning widespread public attention. Though there may have been some staging for this broadcast, such an enthusiastic response would not have been lavished on someone who did not have true integrity.

    In another episode, when Doko was left with the job of financially constructing Toshiba, he cut the size of the company president's office to one-quarter of its original size, and moved top company officials from separate offices to one large room.

    Of course there have been other figures in the history of Japanese government who have stood out in this way, such as Yozan Uesugi, a lord of the Yonezawa Domain during the Edo period, and Moku Onda, a chief retainer of the Matsushiro Domain. These noted administrative leaders lived virtuous lives in poverty as they searched for a correct path of administration. There are no tales of them rushing to spend money on their own dwellings.

    The rebuilding of Diet members' offices had been under consideration since about 1988. Construction started under the Liberal Democratic Party-led government in 2007 after various twists and turns, with the total cost reaching 178.7 billion yen.

    On July 21, Chief Cabinet Secretary Yoshito Sengoku took a swipe at critical news reports on the completion of the offices, warning reporters to be wary of "reduction democracy."

    He was referring to a low-level type of democracy marked by opposition to something even if it is good, due to jealousy or resentment. The original Japanese term, "hikisage demokurashii," was coined by the charismatic political scholar Masao Maruyama. The chief Cabinet secretary's comment matched his character, but such a stance cannot win popular support. The current government administration is intellectual, but it is lacking in the stoicism and sense in benevolent rule that extends back to Moku, Yozan and Doko. (By Takao Yamada, Mainichi Shimbun)

    (Mainichi Japan) July 26, 2010